We're sharing our modern farmhouse exterior materials including limestone, black Hardie board and batten siding, black windows, wood garage doors, and black roof shingles - plus the compromises we made and why.
Disclaimer: this post may contain affiliate links, and every purchase made through these links will give me a small commission (at absolutely no extra cost for you!) AS AN AMAZON ASSOCIATE AND REWARDSTYLE MEMBER, I EARN FROM QUALIFYING PURCHASES. See Privacy Policy for additional info.
Building a custom home on rural property comes with a lot of big decisions - but few feel as permanent as your exterior materials. The siding, stone, windows, and garage doors aren't just design choices… they impact durability, maintenance, long-term cost, and even resale value.
When we started planning our modern farmhouse exterior, I knew I wanted something timeless, high contrast, and strong enough to handle our Canadian winters. But I also wanted warmth and character - not something that felt too stark or trendy.
Today I'm breaking down every exterior material we chose for our farmhouse build - including our limestone front, black board and batten Hardie siding, black windows, and wood-looking garage doors - and exactly why we picked each one. If you're planning a custom build, especially on rural property, this post will help you think through both the aesthetic and practical sides of your decisions.
Modern Farmhouse Exterior Material Breakdown
Before diving into each exterior material, here's a quick overview of what we chose, why we chose it, and how each decision fit into our overall budget and maintenance goals.
| Exterior Material | Why We Chose It | Budget Level | Maintenance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Limestone front | Timeless, durable, and adds natural texture to the front of our home | Higher investment | Low maintenance |
| Black board and batten Hardie siding | Gives the house a bold modern farmhouse look while being durable for our climate | Mid to high | Lower maintenance than wood |
| Black exterior windows | Adds contrast, definition, and a clean modern look | Higher investment | Low maintenance |
| Wood-look carriage-style garage doors | Warms up the black exterior and adds farmhouse character | Mid range | Lower maintenance than real wood |
| Black asphalt roof shingles | Helped us stay on budget while still keeping the exterior cohesive | Budget-friendly | Standard roof maintenance |
Modern Farmhouse Exterior Materials We Chose
When designing our modern farmhouse, choosing the right exterior materials was one of the biggest decisions we made. We wanted a timeless look that balanced durability, curb appeal, and budget - which led us to limestone, black Hardie board and batten siding, black windows, and classic black roof shingles. Here's exactly what we chose and why each material made sense for our rural build.
Our Overall Exterior Vision
We were going for:
- Modern farmhouse
- High contrast black + natural textures
- Classic materials that age well
- Low maintenance (as much as possible)
- Strong curb appeal from the long driveway
Because our home sits back from the road with a long rural driveway, I wanted the exterior to make an impact - but still feel warm and welcoming.
1. Limestone Front Exterior
Why We Chose Limestone
We chose natural limestone for the front of our home because:
- It's timeless
- It feels high-end and substantial
- It ties beautifully into Ontario's natural landscape
- It adds texture against black siding
Limestone has that old-world, European farmhouse feel (that I love!!!) - and since we're building in Ontario, it felt very authentic to our region.
Durability & Maintenance
One of the biggest reasons we felt confident using limestone:
- It handles freeze-thaw cycles well
- It's extremely durable
- It doesn't require repainting
- It ages beautifully
For a rural property exposed to wind and snow, that durability mattered a lot.
Cost Consideration
Stone is more expensive than siding, especially natural stone. But we used it intentionally - focused on the front elevation where curb appeal matters most. It was a splurge… but one that will never go out of style! And honestly.. I love it SO much.
2. Black Board and Batten Hardie Siding
Why We Chose Hardie Board
We chose James Hardie board and batten siding for a few key reasons:
- Fibre cement is incredibly durable
- It resists moisture, rot, and pests
- It holds paint better than wood
- It gives that classic farmhouse vertical line look
Board and batten was non-negotiable for me. It adds height visually and gives that traditional farmhouse structure - but in black, it feels updated and modern.
Why Black?
Black siding:
- Creates bold contrast against limestone
- Looks stunning in winter against snow
- Photographs beautifully (important for content 😉)
- Feels timeless but dramatic
Yes, black absorbs more heat - but with proper insulation and ventilation, this isn't a major issue.
Maintenance Reality
Hardie siding requires far less upkeep than wood. It will eventually need repainting (down the road), but not nearly as frequently. For a busy family build, low maintenance was a must.
3. Black Windows (Exterior)
Black windows completely change the look of a farmhouse exterior.
Why We Chose Black Exterior Frames
- Sharp contrast against limestone and siding
- Adds architectural definition
- Feels modern and clean
- Ties everything together
We went with black exterior frames for bold curb appeal - but kept the interior white to keep rooms feeling bright and airy.
Things to Consider
- Black windows can cost slightly more
- They show dust more than white
- They are more permanent visually
But honestly? They're one of my favorite exterior choices we made.
4. Wood-Look Carriage-Style Garage Doors
This might be the detail that pulls everything together.
Against black siding and limestone, the wood garage doors add warmth and balance.
Why We Chose Wood-Look Garage Doors
We loved the warmth and character that wood garage doors bring to a modern farmhouse - but we also wanted something practical and lower maintenance for our rural home.
These wood-look carriage-style doors gave us the best of both worlds:
- Softens the black exterior
- Adds natural warmth and texture
- Feels custom and high-end
- Brings in classic farmhouse character
- Lower maintenance than real wood
Without the wood element, the house could have felt too stark.
The Low-Maintenance Bonus
While real wood garage doors are beautiful, they often require regular sealing, staining, or refinishing - especially in Canadian climates with snow, moisture, and changing temperatures.
Our wood-look garage doors gave us that same cozy farmhouse feel with much less upkeep, which made them an easy choice for our build. For us, they were the perfect balance between style and practicality.
5. Black Roof Shingles vs Metal Roofing (Our Budget Compromise)
If I'm being completely honest… I originally wanted a black metal roof.
There's just something about a modern farmhouse with a standing seam metal roof that feels classic, architectural, and a little bit European. It adds so much character.
But when we ran the numbers?
Metal was significantly more expensive.
And we had to make some tough decisions.
Why We Chose Black Asphalt Shingles Instead
In the end, we went with traditional black asphalt shingles for a few reasons:
- Much more budget-friendly
- Faster installation
- Widely available
- Still gives us that strong black contrast look
On a large rural build, costs add up quickly. We decided to invest in areas that were harder to change later (like limestone and windows) and save where we could without sacrificing the overall look.
Do I Regret Not Doing Metal?
Honestly?
No.
Would a black metal roof have been stunning? Absolutely.
But our black shingles still:
- Tie beautifully into the black siding and windows
- Keep the exterior cohesive
- Maintain that modern farmhouse feel
- Help us stay on budget
And staying on budget matters more than having every single "dream" feature.
How These Exterior Materials Work Together
What I love most is how each material balances the others:
- Limestone = texture + tradition
- Black Hardie board = bold + modern
- Black windows = architectural definition
- Wood garage doors = warmth
It feels like a modern farmhouse - but not trendy. It feels grounded and substantial.
And most importantly? It fits our rural property perfectly.
If You're Choosing Exterior Materials for a Rural Build
Here's my advice:
- Think long-term durability first
- Consider climate
- Choose one bold element and balance it
- Invest where curb appeal matters most
- Don't follow trends blindly
Exterior materials are one of the hardest things to change later. Make sure you love them.
How to Choose Exterior Materials for a Modern Farmhouse
Choosing exterior materials for a modern farmhouse is about more than just picking what looks good on Pinterest. You need to consider your climate, long-term maintenance, durability, and of course, your overall budget. In colder regions like Ontario, materials need to withstand freeze-thaw cycles, snow, wind, and moisture - which makes options like fibre cement siding, natural stone, and quality roofing materials especially important.
Start by deciding on your main statement material - whether that's stone, siding, or roofing - and then build around it with complementary textures and tones. Modern farmhouse exteriors typically combine contrast (like black siding or windows) with warmth (such as wood accents or natural stone) to create balance. Think about how each material works together rather than choosing everything in isolation.
Most importantly, prioritize longevity over trends. Exterior materials are expensive and difficult to change later. Invest in timeless elements that fit your property and lifestyle, and be prepared to make a few compromises along the way. A well-planned exterior will feel cohesive, grounded, and beautiful for decades - not just for the next design trend cycle.
Modern Farmhouse Exterior Materials FAQ
The best exterior materials for a modern farmhouse are durable, timeless, and full of texture. Popular options include board and batten siding, natural stone, black or white window frames, wood-look garage doors, metal roofing, and asphalt shingles. The key is choosing materials that balance contrast, warmth, and long-term maintenance.
Yes, black board and batten siding is a beautiful choice for a modern farmhouse exterior. It creates a bold, high-contrast look and gives the home that classic vertical farmhouse detail. If you choose a durable option like Hardie board or fibre cement siding, it can also be more practical than real wood siding.
Black exterior windows are worth it if you want a modern, defined look. They add contrast, frame the exterior beautifully, and pair especially well with limestone, white siding, black siding, and wood accents. They can cost more than standard white windows, but they make a big impact on curb appeal.
Limestone is a great exterior material because it feels timeless, natural, and substantial. It adds texture and warmth to a home, and it works especially well with modern farmhouse designs. It can be a higher investment, but using it on the front elevation is a smart way to get the look without covering the entire house.
A metal roof can be worth the extra cost if it fits your budget and long-term goals. It has a beautiful architectural look and can last a long time, but it is usually more expensive upfront than asphalt shingles. For our build, we chose black asphalt shingles as a budget-friendly compromise while still keeping the modern farmhouse exterior cohesive.
More From Our House Build
Building our custom farmhouse has been such a journey, and I've documented each major stage along the way. If you're planning your own build or just love following house projects, here are some more posts from our build series:
- Custom Farmhouse Floor Plans - See how we designed the layout of our modern farmhouse and the decisions that shaped our floor plan.
- Building Our 700-Metre Rural Driveway - Everything that went into creating our long country driveway.
- Drilling a Well on Rural Property - What the well drilling process looked like and what we learned along the way.
- Excavation, Slab Prep & Foundation Walls - A behind-the-scenes look at preparing our property and getting the foundation underway.
- Our Farmhouse Framing Process - Watching the structure go up was one of the most exciting milestones of the build.
Final Thoughts on Our Modern Farmhouse Exterior Materials
Building a custom home is such a mix of dreaming big and making practical decisions. While I had a clear vision for our modern farmhouse exterior - limestone, black board and batten, black windows, and warm wood garage doors - there were still compromises along the way (hello, metal roof dreams). But what I've learned through this process is that a beautiful home isn't about getting every single "wish list" item. It's about choosing materials that work together, fit your climate, support your budget, and create a look you'll love for decades.
At the end of the day, I'm so proud of how our exterior came together. It feels timeless, grounded, and perfectly suited to our rural property. If you're in the middle of planning your own build, my biggest advice is this: invest where it matters most to you, be realistic about trade-offs, and remember that thoughtful design always wins over trends. I can't wait to share more of our build journey with you.
Until next time,
As Seen on TikTok
Come behind the scenes of our farmhouse build, decor projects, and cozy everyday life. Tap a video to watch, then follow @nikkisplate on TikTok for more.
Watch this video on TikTok
Watch this video on TikTok
Watch this video on TikTok
Leave a Reply